Holiday Shoppers Are Thinking Twice. Here's How Brands Can Win Them Over.

By Adam Ortman, CEO, Kinetic319

Holiday shoppers are making their lists and checking them twice. But this year, they’re also thinking twice before putting something in their carts.


Economic uncertainty hasn’t stopped consumers from spending (Deloitte expects holiday retail sales to grow 4% to 4.8% this year), but it has made them more selective. They’re comparing prices, questioning whether products are worth the cost, and weighing purchases more carefully. They’re still willing to spend on things they want, need, or believe will improve their lives or bring joy to their family, but they may need a little more convincing.


For retailers, that raises an important question this holiday season: how do you convince someone to buy when they’re looking for reasons to hold onto their money?

Give shoppers a reason to choose your product beyond the price tag. Show them what makes it worth their money.

— Adam Ortman, CEO, Kinetic319

With shoppers watching their budgets more closely, it’s tempting to respond with bigger discounts. And while a good deal can certainly help, there’s more to getting someone to buy than shaving a percentage off the price.


Just think about your own shopping habits. You might happily spend more on something you know will last, from a brand you trust, or on a product that simply does the job better. Shoppers judge prices against what they believe something should cost based on previous prices and competing offers. Even a 50% discount isn’t much of a deal if you don’t think the product is worth buying in the first place.


Give shoppers a reason to choose your product beyond the price tag. Show them what makes it worth their money, whether that’s better quality, greater convenience, or something they’ll appreciate long after the holidays.

Consumers Have More Information and Less Patience

Value Doesn’t Just Mean Price

Shoppers have more information at their fingertips than ever before, and they’re using it. They can compare prices, read reviews, check out competing products, and even turn to AI tools to help decide what to buy. That great deal you advertised? It takes only a few seconds to find out whether it's truly a bargain.


Vague promises and inflated discounts won’t cut it anymore. Consumers can check your claims, and if something doesn’t add up, they have plenty of other options.


But there’s an upside here, too. Brands that make shopping easier can stand out. Clear product descriptions, honest pricing, helpful comparisons, and simple return policies all give customers one less reason to hesitate. The more questions you answer upfront, the easier it is to hit that “buy” button.

Confidence Is a Competitive Advantage

Even when budgets are tight, people still spend on things that bring them joy, make life easier, or help them connect with others. They just want to feel good about the decision.


Consider this: Two retailers are selling the same product. One pushes a limited-time discount, and the other explains why the product is worth buying, offers reliable delivery, and makes returns easy. Which one would you trust?


You can’t control the economy or how much consumers have to spend. But you can make it easier for shoppers to see the value in a purchase.


This holiday season, giving shoppers that confidence could be the difference between making a sale and losing one.