RETAILERS ARE MAKING THEIR LISTS AND CHECKING THEM TWICE.

How brands are turning to social media and personalization to make this holiday season a little nicer!

By Catrina Van Dyck​​​​​​​, Associate Partner, Columbus Consulting

Most retailers have spent the last 10 months analyzing holiday 2025, reviewing what worked and what didn’t, developing their financial plans and assortments, adjusting for economic impacts and current business trends to land on their final product offerings for Holiday 2026. In some cases, they are using predictive analytics to identify shifts in competitor assortments or pricing, highlighting business opportunities for the Holiday season to come. Those AI tools work well for comparisons in existing product categories with lots of data points (the science of retail) but aren’t necessarily able to predict fast social media trends like Whimsy-maxxing or the growing personalization trend (the art of retail).

Social media trends are becoming more important to consumers but can be hard for retailers to respond to as they occur almost instantly, have huge momentum, and then are over before most can respond. While some trends can be better predicted, there are always those surprises that catch the industry off-guard.


Whimsy-maxxing, for example, is a social media trend that presents a huge retail opportunity but may be difficult for most brands to hop on the preverbal bandwagon. The trend is where one intentionally adds playful joy to their daily life and environment. Making hearts in your coffee, embellishing your laptop with cartoon character stickers, bedazzling your phone case, layering on costume jewelry and bag charms are just a few fun ways to bring childlike joy and make you smile throughout your day.


The continued significance of social media and the trends that emerge from the various platforms, like whimsy-maxxing, is motivating fashion and accessory retailers to assess their agility, sourcing and supply chains in order to pivot quickly and take advantage of social triggers. Other retailers, like crafting chains Michael’s and Hobby Lobby, are leveraging their assortments and merchandising to flex existing products via themed presentations and signage to capitalize on trend opportunities. The key is to build an operational process that can react without being disruptive to the business.


Personalization is another good example of a trend that is being adopted by retail in a scalable/profitable way. Even luxury brands who value tradition and quality/craftsmanship are leaning into personalization with custom initials, colors and limited-edition stock. Some considerations, however, need to be addressed even in an agile product environment. In some instances, personalization may require equipment, dedicated shop space, and trained staff to support the experience. Yet, it may still be worth the investment as customization does have great returns in customer loyalty and in new customer acquisition through gift-giving.

Being responsive to trends is key to staying relevant yet innovation can come from customization and collaboration as well. Accessories have become incremental to small leather goods and travel brands—including colored name tags (Tumi), bag charms (Coach and others) and mix and match straps (MZ Wallace). Even destination pop-up shops and regional exclusives, (think Jelly Cat NY and Paris) and co-branded assortments like Veuve Clicquot champagne tins at Selfridge’s all add to the creation of retail magic.


In an era where data and science are driving so much of our decision making, retail is still an industry that needs human touch and interactivity. According to NRF’s Holiday Outlook for this year, retail is expected to grow at 4,2% (well above recent averages) and, as an interesting highlight, store shopping is predicted to increase, noting a measurable return to brick and mortar. So, with endless data points and now artificial intelligence entering the equation, retailers need to be mindful of staying unique and special. Afterall, Santa may always know what you want, but brands need to rely on hindsight, predictability, social cues and a little art to balance the commerce.


In an era where data and science are driving so much of our decision making, retail is still an industry that needs human touch and interactivity.

— Catrina Van Dyck​​​​​​​, Associate Partner, Columbus Consulting

It’s That Time of Year Again

The New Social Media Mix & A Touch of Personalization on Top

Build, Buy or Partner

Science + Art = Holiday Joy